Everyday, with Dr. Elias Locke
Friday, November 20, 2026 · A fictional column from the Electric Icarus universe, created by Jon LaBelle
The Committee of Second Opinions
The town convened its Committee of Second Opinions on Friday, after the mayor complained that the first opinions had become too difficult to defend.
Mr. Crimp supplied the committee’s newest instrument: a brass cabinet with two speaking trumpets. One trumpet agreed with any statement placed in the input tray. The other disagreed. Both were connected to the same crank.
“Balanced deliberation,” said the mayor.
Miss Bellweather, the clerk, asked whether either trumpet checked the evidence.
“Why should it?” Crimp replied. “We have ensured that every question receives two sides.”
I submitted a simple proposition: the courthouse clock was seven minutes fast.
The left trumpet announced, “Absolutely correct.” The right announced, “Entirely false.”
Miss Bellweather consulted the railway clock, noted the time, and asked which trumpet had made a measurement.
Neither answered. Crimp turned the crank again. Both repeated themselves, louder.
The mayor looked pleased. “Now we have a lively debate.”
“You have a pair of noises,” I said. “A debate requires reasons that can be examined.”
To demonstrate, I asked whether the bridge had reopened after its inspection. The machine issued its usual approval and disapproval. Miss Bellweather telephoned the maintenance office. The damaged walkway remained closed, pending repairs. That answer was neither an opinion nor an insult to the mayor; it was the current condition of the bridge.
Crimp adjusted a screw. “We can make the disagreeing trumpet more polite.”
“Politeness is welcome,” I told him. “But it will not make the railing stronger.”
A councilman proposed a third trumpet to offer compromise. The mayor suggested a fourth to represent public sentiment. Miss Bellweather suggested a window.
“A window?” asked Crimp.
“So we can look outside before purchasing another trumpet.”
We carried the cabinet to the courthouse steps. Through the open door came the sounds of traffic, a distant train, and the maintenance crew unloading lumber. The machine offered four opinions about the noise. Nobody bothered to record them.
Miss Bellweather wrote down the bridge’s inspection number and the date of its next review. The mayor reluctantly agreed that the committee might occasionally consult the people doing the work.
By closing time, the brass cabinet had been reassigned to the annual debate tournament. There, its talent for producing instant opposition would be considered a novelty rather than a method.
I added one sentence to my field notebook: disagreement is not evidence merely because it stands opposite agreement. Two unsupported answers do not become knowledge by facing one another across a table.
